Put two analytics tools on the same WordPress site and they’ll disagree by the end of the first day. Add your host’s stats panel and you have three numbers, often far apart, for the same readers.
Usually all of them are working. Each tool counts something slightly different and leaves out different traffic. Once you know where the gaps come from, you can tell an expected difference from a real problem.
A visitor means different things
This gap only shows up over ranges longer than a day, and it can be large.
Google Analytics 4 tries to recognise the same person across visits, with a cookie. Over a month, someone who reads your site on ten different days is one user.
Vireo Analytics doesn’t use cookies. It tells visitors apart within a single day and starts fresh the next day, so over a month its Visitors figure is each day’s visitors added together. The same reader who came on ten days counts ten times. Vireo labels the card “daily uniques, summed” when the range is longer than a day, so you can see which definition you’re looking at.
Take a hypothetical month where 1,000 people each visit on three different days. GA4 reports around 1,000 users. Vireo reports around 3,000 visitors. Both are right about what they measure.
For a single day the two definitions line up, so compare one day at a time if you want to check them against each other. The what’s counted docs explain how Vireo counts visitors without tracking people across days, which is what the cookie does.
Bots land in different places
Server-side stats, such as your host’s panel or a log analyser, count every request. Search engines, SEO tools, uptime monitors and AI crawlers all count as visits there, and on a small site they can outnumber people.
Script-based tools like GA4 only count a visit when JavaScript runs in a browser. Most crawlers never run it, so they never show up. The bots that do run JavaScript, such as headless browsers, get through unless the tool’s own list recognises them.
Vireo checks requests on the server and again when its script reports a view, so it catches both kinds and keeps them out of your totals. It tells you what it removed: the line under the totals on the Overview says how many requests it kept out and what share of everything that was. How much of your traffic is bots covers the filtering.
So expect your host’s figure to be the highest, often by a wide margin.
Each tool skips different people
Every tool has a list of visits it chooses not to count, and the lists don’t match.
- Vireo doesn’t count logged-in administrators unless you switch that on. GA4 counts you unless you’ve filtered your own traffic.
- Vireo doesn’t count visitors whose browser sends Do Not Track or Global Privacy Control. Check whether your other tool honours them.
- If GA4 runs behind a cookie banner, it only measures visitors who accept, or it estimates the rest. Vireo stores nothing on the visitor’s device and counts without waiting for consent, unless you’ve told it to wait.
- Many ad blockers and privacy browsers block Google Analytics by name.
- Excluded IP addresses, paths and countries only apply in the tool where you set them.
Pageviews are counted differently too
Pageviews disagree less than visitors, but they still drift apart:
- Vireo counts a page by its path and drops the query string, so
/pricing/?ref=newsletterand/pricing/are one page. Other tools may list them separately. - A page the browser prefetched or prerendered, but nobody looked at, isn’t a view in Vireo.
- One visitor counts for at most five views of the same page, and fifty in total, per day. Reloads past that go into the bot report instead.
Days end at different times
Vireo follows your site’s timezone, as set in WordPress under Settings, General. GA4 uses the reporting time zone of the property. If one is UTC and the other is New York, every “day” is shifted by several hours, and a traffic burst late in the evening lands on different dates in each tool.
Imported history keeps the old tool’s rules
When you import your history into Vireo, each imported day keeps whatever the old tool counted. GA4’s bot handling, its consent gaps and its users all come across as they were. So a chart that runs from imported months into Vireo’s own months can show a step at the switch that isn’t a change in readers.
A few details from the importers:
- GA4 history arrives as daily users, so a month of imported GA4 data reads higher in Vireo than GA4’s own monthly user count. GA4 counted a returning reader once for the month, and Vireo adds up the days.
- Outbound clicks, file downloads, form submissions and your own custom events come across from GA4, as Vireo events.
- Some tools never recorded visitors at all, so their imported days show pageviews only.
The Year in review marks imported months apart from the months Vireo counted, and says which tool each one came from. The import comparison lists what each source brings.
Search Console counts clicks, not visits
A common version of the gap: the analytics plugin says 30 visitors came from Google, and Search Console says Google sent 50. Search Console counts clicks on your listing in Google. An analytics tool counts a reader only after the page loads and its script runs, so the two numbers measure different moments.
- A click is counted when someone leaves Google for your site, per Google’s definition. A reader who closes the tab before your page finishes loading is a click and never a visit.
- Google’s own notes say some tools only track users who have JavaScript enabled. Ad blockers, privacy browsers and cookie banners cut the analytics side further, as described above.
- Search Console also reports Discover and Google News clicks, in their own reports. Check which report a number came from before comparing it.
- Search Console labels each day in Pacific Time, so a click late in the evening in Europe can land on the next day in one tool and the same day in the other.
- Search Console’s privacy filtering means the Performance report doesn’t show all data, so the query table won’t add up to every click either.
Two things push the other way. Someone who clicks your result, goes back and clicks it again counts as one click. Search Console also removes duplicates and visits from robots before it reports.
Once you connect Search Console, Vireo lists the Google searches behind each post on that post’s stats screen, with clicks, impressions and average position. That shows what Google reports for the post beside what your site counted. The two still won’t match exactly, for the reasons above.
Which number to trust
Pick one tool as your record and compare it with itself. A rise or a fall in the same tool, with the same rules, means something. A gap between two tools mostly tells you how differently they count.
If you’re checking a new tool against an old one, run both for a couple of weeks and compare the shape of the daily chart, not the totals. The peaks and the quiet days should line up. If they do, the difference is definitions. If one tool shows a spike the other doesn’t, look at the bots line and the referrers for that day.
And if Vireo shows fewer visits than you expected, the troubleshooting page lists what to check before you assume something’s missing.